Accountability without authority
You’ve been given important responsibility. The outcome matters, the expectations are high and your performance will be judged on whether you deliver but there’s one problem.
The people you need to make it happen don’t report to you. The resources sit elsewhere and some of the decisions depend on colleagues with different priorities. Although everyone supports the ambition in principle, securing their commitment is proving surprisingly difficult.
You’re accountable for the result, but much of what determines success sits outside your direct control.
It’s a familiar frustration for senior leaders, particularly those working across organisational boundaries, leading transformation or operating in complex governance arrangements.
The instinct is often to work harder at influencing, communicating or building relationships, which is sometimes exactly what’s needed. However, sometimes the problem is more fundamental. You've been given accountability without the authority needed to exercise it.
Responsibility and authority aren’t the same thing
Imagine a director appointed to lead a major transformation programme.
The board has approved the strategy, and the director has been given responsibility for delivery, whilst everyone agrees the work is important. Yet the programme depends on several departments changing how they operate. Their leaders have their own performance targets, financial pressures and competing priorities. None reports directly to the programme director.
Six months later, progress is patchy.
The director spends increasing amounts of time persuading colleagues, resolving disagreements and chasing commitments. Senior sponsors want reassurance that delivery is on track, while the people whose cooperation is essential continue to negotiate what they can realistically contribute. Eventually, the director starts wondering whether they’re simply not influential enough.
But is that really the problem?
Perhaps the organisation has created a role with significant responsibility but insufficient authority. Perhaps the board has endorsed the ambition without resolving the competing accountabilities that make delivery difficult. Or perhaps the director is struggling to exercise authority that is available to them, but which feels uncomfortable to claim. These are different problems which require different responses.
What systems psychodynamics helps us see
My training in systems psychodynamic approaches to coaching at the Tavistock Institute has strongly influenced how I understand situations like this.
One particularly useful framework is BART: Boundaries, Authority, Role and Task.
It can offer a way of examining whether the conditions around a leadership role support what the person is expected to achieve.
Examples of how this comes to life can include:
Boundaries: Where does your responsibility begin and end? Where do decisions or responsibilities overlap with those of others?
Authority: What authority have you formally been given, what authority do others recognise and what authority are you prepared to exercise?
Role: What are you being asked to do, and how does that compare with what others implicitly expect of you?
Task: What is the shared purpose, and do the people involved genuinely understand and commit to it? How does this relate to the primary task of the organisation?
On paper, these questions may seem straightforward but in practice, the answers can be surprisingly complicated:
A senior leader might have clear, written responsibilities but discover that decisions still require informal approval from someone who previously held the role.
A founder might appoint an experienced executive to run the business but continue intervening in operational decisions.
An NHS leader might be expected to deliver improvements across organisational boundaries while the people and resources needed remain accountable to separate institutions.
These situations aren’t necessarily evidence of poor leadership. They may reveal tensions in how authority and accountability have been organised.
The authority you’re given and the authority you take
Systems psychodynamic thinking also distinguishes between authority granted by others and the authority we take up ourselves.
A job title may provide formal legitimacy, but it doesn’t automatically mean we feel authorised to act. Our professional identities, previous experiences and relationships all influence how comfortably we exercise (or respond to) authority.
For example, someone promoted because of their leadership potential may find it difficult to challenge former peers. This can be a particularly challenging shift for senior clinical roles in healthcare, where someone may step into role for a limited period – one day they are peers, then ‘boss’, yet knowing they will return to peer just a couple of years later.
Other examples include a leader brought into an established organisation may hesitate to question longstanding practices. Someone working alongside a powerful founder may become accustomed to seeking approval even when their role technically allows independent decisions.
Sometimes the organisational system reinforces this hesitation too. Colleagues bypass the new leader, senior figures continue making informal decisions, or conflicting messages leave everyone uncertain about whose judgement should prevail.
Over time, the leader can become caught between two uncomfortable positions: feeling responsible for everything while feeling authorised to decide very little, which can have a real impact on confidence and performance.
When the frustration becomes part of the problem
When leaders feel unable to exercise authority, their understandable frustration can begin to shape how they behave. Some respond by working harder, becoming the person who follows up every commitment and resolves every obstacle. Others withdraw, deciding there’s little point challenging decisions they cannot influence. Some become increasingly directive, attempting to compensate for limited authority through personal force. Each response can inadvertently reinforce the original difficulty.
The leader who continually rescues delivery may allow others to avoid taking responsibility. The leader who withdraws may confirm colleagues’ assumptions that their role carries little influence. The leader who pushes harder may generate resistance that makes collaboration even more difficult.
This is why simply telling someone to be more assertive, confident or resilient may miss what is happening. We need to understand both the organisational conditions and the leader’s response to them.
What might help you move forward?
If you recognise this situation, I’d suggest starting with three questions.
What authority does the task actually require?
Rather than beginning with your job description, work backwards from the outcome.
Which decisions need to be made? Who controls the necessary resources? Whose cooperation is essential? Where are the dependencies?
This helps distinguish between authority you already have, authority you need to negotiate, and authority that must be explicitly granted by others.
What are you taking responsibility for that belongs elsewhere?
Senior leaders can become remarkably skilled at absorbing problems that the organisation hasn’t resolved.
You may be compensating for unclear governance, conflicting priorities or colleagues who haven’t been required to commit to the shared task. The question isn’t how to avoid responsibility but how to make responsibility visible and appropriately shared.
Sometimes the most effective leadership move is to bring an unresolved tension back to those with the authority to address it.
What is happening to your own authority in the process?
Notice how the situation is affecting you.
Are you seeking permission unnecessarily? Avoiding a conversation because you anticipate resistance? Taking on additional work rather than challenging an unrealistic expectation? Equally, are you treating a structural problem as evidence that you’re personally not good enough?
Understanding your own responses can help you distinguish what needs to change in your leadership from what needs to change around you.
Seeing the problem differently changes what becomes possible
In my coaching practice, I work with senior leaders navigating situations where organisational complexity, difficult relationships and unclear expectations affect their ability to lead effectively.
One client, an investment professional in a rapidly growing business, was working within changing leadership arrangements and inconsistent expectations. Another, a senior leader in patient co-production, was experiencing organisational and team dynamics that were undermining their effectiveness and authority.
Although the circumstances differed, both illustrate why it’s important to look beyond individual capability and consider the context in which someone is trying to exercise leadership.
My work isn’t about providing a formula for gaining more influence. It’s about helping leaders understand what’s really happening, including the organisational dynamics and their own responses, so they can make more effective choices.
That might mean approaching a difficult relationship differently, clarifying expectations with a senior sponsor, renegotiating responsibilities or recognising that a problem cannot be resolved through personal effort alone.
Accountability needs more than good intentions
Being accountable for results you cannot fully control is often unavoidable at a senior level. Senior leadership increasingly involves working through relationships, negotiation and shared authority rather than relying on hierarchy alone. There’s a difference between leading through interdependence and being expected to deliver without the conditions needed to succeed though. Good leadership requires the judgement to recognise that difference.
If you’re finding yourself working harder and harder to deliver something that depends on decisions outside your control, perhaps the most useful question isn’t, how can I become more influential? It might be: what authority does this work actually require, and what needs to change for me to exercise it effectively?
If you’re navigating unclear authority, competing expectations or difficult organisational relationships, my one-to-one Leadership Partnership offers a confidential opportunity to examine what’s happening, challenge assumptions and find a more effective way forward.
Set up a time to talk via catherine@catherineharrisoncoach.com




Comments