Your leadership team looks good on paper, so why isn’t it working?
You’ve recruited capable people (at great expense) who have impressive track records, relevant experience and a shared commitment to the organisation’s success. Yet something isn’t quite working.
Decisions take longer than they should. Difficult issues keep returning to your desk. Meetings are productive on the surface, but the conversations that really matter seem to happen afterwards. People agree to things in the room, only for progress to stall once everyone returns to their own teams.
You may find yourself wondering whether you’ve got the right people, whether expectations are sufficiently clear, or whether you need to be more directive.
These are reasonable questions but they may not get to the heart of the problem. A collection of capable leaders doesn’t automatically make a capable leadership team.
The problem may not be the people
When a senior team struggles, the instinct is often to look at individual performance. Perhaps someone isn’t sufficiently collaborative, another is too dominant, or a third seems reluctant to take responsibility.
Sometimes these assessments are accurate. Individual capability and behaviour matter enormously but they are only part of the picture.
Since my training in systems psychodynamic approaches at the Tavistock Institute, I’ve become particularly interested in what happens between people, and how the wider organisation influences those relationships.
A leadership team isn’t simply a collection of individuals bringing their skills to a shared task. It’s also a social system, shaped by its history, relationships, power dynamics, expectations and the pressures it is under.
These forces can produce behaviours that make little sense when we look at individuals in isolation.
Consider a hypothetical example
A chief executive has assembled an experienced executive team. Each director is effective within their own area, but collective decisions are painfully slow. Everyone has a view, yet nobody seems willing to make the difficult trade-offs.
The CEO becomes increasingly frustrated and starts intervening more frequently to move things along. This works in the short term. Decisions do get made.
Over time though, directors become more inclined to defer upwards, rather than work through disagreements with one another. The CEO feels increasingly indispensable, while privately worrying that the team lacks ownership.
The problem now looks like insufficient accountability. However, what if the team’s dependency on the CEO and the CEO’s increasingly directive approach are reinforcing one another? More assertive leadership might actually make matters worse.
What’s happening beneath the surface?
Systems psychodynamic thinking offers a useful way of examining these patterns.
One influential idea, developed by Wilfred Bion, is that groups can move away from their shared task and become caught up in unconscious ways of managing anxiety.
For example, a group may become overly dependent on a leader to provide answers, rather than exercising its collective judgement. Or it may divide into competing camps, each convinced that the other is the problem.
These aren’t inevitable behaviours, nor should we assume that every disagreement or delay has an unconscious explanation. This perspective invites us to ask different questions though:
What has this team come to expect from its leader?
Which conversations are consistently avoided, and why?
Where does responsibility actually sit, rather than where the organisational chart says it sits?
What happens when someone challenges the prevailing view?
Is the team working towards a genuinely shared purpose, or is each member primarily protecting their own area?
These questions can reveal dynamics that another away-day, revised terms of reference or set of behavioural commitments might not resolve.
When the system shapes the leader
One of the more challenging aspects of senior leadership is recognising that we’re not simply observing the dynamics around us, we’re participating in them.
This is something I explore in my coaching work.
For example, I’ve supported a senior leader whose effectiveness was being undermined by organisational complexity, difficult team relationships and challenges to their professional authority.
The work involved more than considering how to respond to particular individuals. It meant examining the wider context, the expectations operating around the leader, and how their own responses were affecting their ability to influence events.
Similarly, I’ve worked with an investment professional navigating unclear expectations and changing leadership arrangements in a rapidly growing business. Understanding the organisational dynamics, rather than treating every difficulty as an individual performance problem, was an important part of developing a more effective approach.
These experiences reinforce something I see repeatedly: the behaviour we want to change may be sustained by the very relationships and structures within which it occurs.
That doesn’t remove individual responsibility, but it helps us understand how to exercise it more effectively.
What can you do?
If your senior team isn’t working as well as it should, I’d suggest starting with three things.
First, look at the patterns rather than the personalities.
Notice what keeps happening. Do difficult decisions repeatedly come back to you? Does one person always challenge while others remain silent? Are commitments made collectively but treated as optional afterwards?
Patterns offer clues about how the team is functioning, beyond individual strengths and weaknesses.
Second, examine your own contribution.
This can be uncomfortable, particularly when you’re working hard to hold everything together.
Ask yourself what happens when you don’t intervene. Do you allow disagreements to be worked through, or step in because the tension feels unproductive? Have you unintentionally become the person everyone expects to resolve uncertainty?
The aim isn’t self-blame but to identify where you have influence over a pattern that may otherwise keep repeating.
Third, create space to discuss how the team works, not just what it delivers.
Senior teams spend considerable time reviewing performance, risks and strategic priorities. Far fewer routinely examine the quality of their collective work.
That means asking questions such as: What are we finding difficult to resolve together? Where are we relying too heavily on individuals? What might we need to change about how we exercise collective responsibility?
These conversations need care. They can surface tensions that have been managed through avoidance for some time. When approached thoughtfully, they can open up possibilities that remain invisible when attention stays exclusively on the agenda.
The real measure of a leadership team
A strong leadership team isn’t one where everyone agrees, or where every member is exceptional in their own right.
It’s one that can use its collective capability to confront difficult realities, exercise sound judgement, make decisions and take shared responsibility for delivering them.
Achieving that requires more than selecting the right individuals. It requires attention to the relationships, authority and organisational conditions that enable those individuals to work effectively together.
Sometimes, the most useful thing a leader can do isn’t to work harder at getting the team to perform. Its to become curious about what is happening between them that is making good performance so difficult.
If you’re leading a capable team that isn’t achieving what you know it could, this may be worth exploring. My Leadership Partnership offers senior leaders a confidential opportunity – through one-to-one coaching - to examine the organisational dynamics affecting their leadership, challenge established assumptions and identify more effective ways forward.




Comments