top of page
Search

When did we forget how to disagree?

Oct 6
4 min read

Recently, I found myself reflecting on something I’ve been party to through coaching sessions more than once, in relation to large, scrutinised, complex organisations.

Two senior leaders, both highly capable and experienced, locked in an aggressive disagreement in full view of colleagues. Raised voices and visible frustration. The kind of exchange that leaves everyone around them uncomfortable and wondering what just happened.


To be clear, this is not the norm. Most senior leaders I work with are thoughtful, professional and genuinely committed to creating healthy environments. Yet incidents like these do occur, or they are witnessed, and when this happens, they raise an interesting question:


What has happened to professional behaviour at work? When did we forget how to disagree?

 

A different view of work

If we go back 100 years, most people did not expect work to meet the range of psychological needs many of us associate with careers today. Work provided income, security, social standing and identity. Professional roles came with behavioural expectations, and professional conduct was closely linked to ideas of duty, respectability and self-restraint. Historical research on the development of the professions highlights how occupation became a key marker of social status and civic identity, while conduct and ethics were central parts of professional life.


The ideal professional was often expected to be dependable, respectful, emotionally controlled and loyal to the institution they served. Of course, we shouldn’t romanticise the past. Many workplaces were hierarchical, exclusionary and overly deferential. People sometimes stayed silent when they should have spoken up so in many ways, we’ve improved.


Today’s organisations need challenge, debate and diverse perspectives. Good governance, innovation and effective decision-making all depend on people being willing to question assumptions and challenge authority when necessary.

Therefore the problem isn’t that people disagree, it’s that some people never learned how to disagree well.

 

The age of the individual

Over recent decades, workplace culture has shifted alongside broader social change. Historians of emotion and work describe a gradual move away from cultures that prized emotional restraint and deference towards cultures that place greater emphasis on self-expression, autonomy and personal identity.  There is so much to celebrate in that shift including people more willing to speak up and being less likely to tolerate poor behaviour simply because it comes from someone senior. We now expect respect, inclusion and the opportunity to contribute.


Yet every strength has a shadow side and sometimes authenticity becomes an excuse for impulsiveness, or confidence becomes defensiveness, and sometimes professional disagreement becomes personal conflict.


In pressured environments, particularly where the stakes are high and scrutiny is constant, status, ego and fear can be in the background for some time before anyone notices.


At the same time, the relationship between organisations and employees has changed. Denise Rousseau describes a move away from the traditional psychological contract, where loyalty and long-term commitment were often exchanged for stability and security, towards more fluid and transactional employment relationships.

That shift has brought opportunity, but it has also brought uncertainty, heightened competition and greater pressure on individual leaders.

 

What it helps to remember

One of the most important lessons of leadership is that disagreement and professionalism are not opposites. In fact, the most effective leaders are often those who can hold both simultaneously. They challenge robustly, remain curious, tolerate being challenged themselves and understand that losing composure rarely strengthens an argument.


When emotions begin to rise, I encourage leaders to pause and ask themselves “Am I trying to solve a problem or am I trying to win?”.

 

Setting standards for others

For those responsible for culture, values statements and competency frameworks will only take you so far. People learn what is acceptable by observing what leaders actually do. If leaders interrupt, undermine or publicly criticise one another, those behaviours spread. If leaders challenge respectfully, listen carefully and manage

conflict constructively, those behaviours spread too.


The daily norm is rarely built through slogans but through how we engage with each other and repeated examples, which means being explicit about expectations:

  • Healthy debate is encouraged.

  • Challenge is welcome.

  • Personal attacks are not.

  • Public humiliation is not.

  • Emotional self-regulation is part of professional responsibility.


Perhaps most importantly, organisations need to stop confusing high performance with leadership maturity. The ability to deliver results and the ability to handle disagreement constructively are not the same thing but both really matter.

 

Helping you stay at your best under pressure

The challenge is that very few leaders behave badly because they set out to. More often, they are operating under pressure, reacting to perceived threats, time constraints or competing demands. This is why thoughtful reflection as part of structured development matters – not just skills training but the chance to test and learn and hone judgement.


One-to-one coaching, high-quality supervision, mentoring, peer reflection groups and structured leadership development all create space for leaders to examine their assumptions, understand their triggers and strengthen their judgement. Evidence reviews and research on leadership coaching suggest that these interventions can support meaningful behaviour change and improvements in leadership effectiveness when done well (CIPD and Centre for Evidence-Based Management, 2023).

 

The real test of professionalism

When I looked into the history of work briefly (as a history grad, this is my idea of fun) – but there will be people reading this with much more knowledge than me, so do get in touch - it seems that every era wrestles with a different challenge. A century ago, many organisations struggled with excessive conformity and deference. Today, some struggle with excessive attachment to individual perspectives and positions.


The answer is neither a return to silence nor a celebration of unfiltered self-expression. The real opportunity for modern leaders is to create environments where people feel safe enough to challenge, disciplined enough to listen, and mature enough to separate disagreement from identity. Balance.


This is because professionalism is not measured by how we behave when everyone agrees with us but by the standard we maintain when they don’t.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page